Tuesday, January 01, 2008

January 2008 Reds(8): Argentina Malbec; Canada Blend; France Blend; Italy Blend, Prim; Spain Blend; USA Cab Sauv, Zin


CHATEAU PIQUE-SEGUE DAUZAN LA VERGNE 1998, Cote de Bergerac, France, 12.5% XD, CP138-1941 $19.17 (Tasted January 23, 2008)

The website describes this as a blend of 70% merlot and 30% cabernet sauvignon and was a Silver Medal winner at Mâcon - Guide Hachette 2001. Described as rich, fruity and full-bodied, comparable to its famous neighbours of St. Emilion. My notes: This is the third tasting since cellaring in December 2001. The last (July, 2007) had the comments '... has improved considerably... is a sophisticated sipper... drinking very well now. A wine such as this could quickly shift my preferences to include 'old world' reds.' A lovely aroma of ripe berries and colour of ruby tinged with garnet, faint terracotta and with long legs.Medium-bodied, very smooth on the first sip with some fine tannins still but not much else - mostly of berries and some cinna-mint and subdued flavours finishing quite long, slightly drying, ending on a faint blackberry note. Has some minty brightness and is an OK sipper - a grown-up with no abrasive traits but not that interesting either. Have with grilled veal or a bacon and cheddar melt. There's no cellar-ability left and it's on the decline now - I dropped it from this month's Bordeaux tastings. 80

TERRA SPARKLING MALBEC 2007,
Mendoza, Argentina, 13.0% D, #055525 $14.85* (Tasted January 19, 2008)  CS

A Vintages release on January 2008 described as "It's not often that we see a bubbly coming out of Argentina, let alone one made with Malbec, but this refreshing fizz is a delight. It's lovely floral and fruity aromas lead to juicy and effervescent red fruit flavours. Terrific as an aperitif or Sunday brunch companion." The back label says "... is a vibrant, deep purple, lightly sparkling red wine. .... perfect as an aperitif. It's full of ripe, wild raspberries and dark plum fruit aromas. ... sweet on the palate yet full of refreshing acidity... " My notes: *This cashed out at $13.85 at the local LCBO - listed as $10 in the US. The website on the back label was not available at the time of tasting. This has a huge outpouring of bubbles against a deep crimson ruby colour, very dense. Aromas of ripe plum and black currant combined with a few raspberries are highlighted by a slight metallic tone. The flavour fights with the dryness showing black currant and fresh berries, very bright on the palate. The freshness of the fruit in the finish drops quickly ending somewhat flat. Very different as a bubbly from the density of colour to the continuous stream of bubbles and fruity flavours. Have as an aperitif with lots of thin italian meats, liver pate on seasoned bagel chips or bacon with maple syrup on hot pancakes. Not for cellaring, a drink-now - and given it's not for everyone, a bargain bubbly. 87-1

CONDADO DE HAZA CRIANZA RIBERO DEL DUERO 2004, Burgos, Spain, 14.0% D, #963348 $24.95 (Tasted January 9, 2008)  CS

A Vintages release on October 27, 2007 described as "The brilliant 2004 Condado de Haza received malolactic fermentation in barrel followed by 15 months in American oak. Purple-colored, it offers up fragrant aromas of cedar, tobacco, black currants and blackberry. There is a supple mouth-feel and generous cherry and black fruit flavors and enough ripe tannins to ensure good longevity. Drink this hedonistic effort now and over the next 10-12 years. 91/100. (Jay Miller, Feb. 2007)." My notes: A deep magenta colour with soft aromas of berries and smoky oak. Let air for an hour to give the fruit more of a chance to show. The flavours hit the palate with smoke, ripe tart berries, forest floor and firm, fine tannins. The tannins carry the day on a long, dry finish of berry fruit and slight tar. For me, not a sipper... a meal red to have with grilled beef, pork back ribs, beef shashlik or lamb souvlaki, egyptian style entrees or hamburgers. Cellaring for another four years could soften the tannins and add some herbal notes. Not a value, maybe someday but not now. 84

ILLUMINATI RIPAROSSO MONTEPULCIANO D'ABRUZZO 2005,
Tuscany, Italy, 13.0% XD, #328997 $12.45 (Tasted January 7, 2008)  CS

A Vintages release on January 5, 2008 described as "A crowd-pleasing wine that will electrify any dinner with its spicy and fruity aromas and flavours. Enjoy with flavourful risotto dishes or with backribs and your best homemade sauce." VH of Winecurrent gives it three and one half (of 5) saying "Uncomplicated, straightforward and honest, this fruity red delivers aromas and flavours of currants, raisins and black plum that intermingle with notes of aromatic bitters. There's good balance with just the right amount of acidity and the tannins are imperceptible. The medium-bodied frame and fruity finish make this a suitable wine to be paired with a lighter-styled red meat aperitif." My notes: Fig aromas quickly change to pleasing plum and berry with long legs draining on the glass. There's a fullness from the first sip with a fine tannin presence edged with soft acid, both adding textures to flavours of woody cherry and fig. An interesting sipper and a good balance between process and fruit which tilts to the riparosso style in a long, dry finish - not objectionably so. Meaty pastas or pizzas are the most likely pairing but this would match any lightish red for grilled beef or pork rib entrees. A drink-now although I think this could develop interesting herbal highlights if cellared for two to four years. A good value for a dry house red. 86-1

TRUCHARD ZINFANDEL NAPA VALLEY 2003, Carneros, USA, 14.2% XD, #054858 $18.95 (Tasted January 5, 2008)  CS

A Vintages release on November 10, 2007 descibed as "This Zin is unique in being the only one produced exclusively from grapes grown in Carneros. The region's cool climate and volcanic, ashy soil combine to create perfect conditions for the cultivation of Zinfandel. Truchard was recognized as one of the 2006 Estate Wineries of the Year by Wine & Spirits magazine." My notes: Aromas of blackberry waft from the glass, warm with an oak edge and inviting. Silky from the first sip with well balanced acid and soft tannins carrying a blackberry and blueberry combination to the palate. The fruit lasts through a long finish ending with a natural sweetness and some mint. I believe this is worth cellaring for several and up to ten years. I'd expect significant introduction of textures and exotic herbal sidelights. An interesting sipper now and would be great paired with prime rib, rack of lamb and mint sauce, a crockpot beef stew or italian hot sausage on a toasted bun. Priced right. 90-2

LA PISARA PRIMITIVO 2004 IGT SALENTO, Puglia, Italy, 14.0% D, #051656 $15.85 (Tasted January 5, 2008)  CS

A Vintages release on January 5, 2008 described as "Primitivo, Zinfandel's Italian alias, has an intriguing nose suggesting plum, hazelnut, fresh fig and blackberry. This version by La Pisara also has a fine tannin core that would suggest potential as a bargain cellar dweller (2-4 years). If you want to enjoy it tonight then pair it with a rare steak and mushrooms." Beppi gives it a thumbs up saying "... should appeal to lovers of Californian Zinfandel... full-bodied and ripe, with rich dark-skinned fruit flavours, chocolate and a hint of raisin...on a velvety frame." My notes: Let air for at least twenty minute for the oak ageing to mellow then lighter plum, blackberry and earthy oak aromas carry the day. A deep opaque ruby in the glass with long legs, an initial breath-taking tartness combined with fig-edged bright black cherry flavours, medium-bodied. The flavours and then a dry finish come across as subdued following such a bright intro and neither stays long. The chocolate isn't worth mentioning. A moderate sipper for lovers of european style reds - the process hides any distinct zinfandel to compare with California zins (see Truchard). Cellaring for up to four years may develop interesting highlights but I wouldn't invest in it. Have with anything beefy... or tomatoey, ie. pastas or cheese stuffed panzarottis. 85

J. LOHR
  SEVEN OAKS CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2005, Paso Robles, USA, 13.5% XD, #656561 $19.95 (Tasted January 3, 2008)  CS

A Vintages release on November 10, 2007 described as "Year after year, this hearty Cab offers excellent value. Rich purple in colour it offers ripe cherry and black currant aromas. Dry, medium full-bodied, with medium tannins and a lengthy finish, this tasty Cab is an excellent match for roast beef or lamb." The website says "... one of the most intensely-colored Estates Cabernets we’ve produced during my [current winemaker] tenure. The wine color has a deep, bright, red-purple hue. An abundance of dark cherry and black currant fruit greets the nose, enhanced by spicy clove and toasty notes. On the palate, the fruit follows through with full weight and a lingering intensity and balance from the tannins. This wine is ready to be enjoyed now, or cellared for 5 years... " My notes: Let air twenty minutes... A deep ruby colour with a violet twist, faint aromas of plums and black cherries. Medium-bodied, with flavours of plums, red cherries and well balanced fine tannin and accomodating tartness - a silky sipper, not bold, not intrusive fruit, a moderate red. The finish is subdued fruit with a moderate dryness which should pair nicely with roasted or grilled beef, rack of lamb, bbq'd pork ribs. Cellaring for a few years should not be a problem just not beneficial, a drink-now. Not as full, bold, spicy or bright as the 2003 (see June 2006 tasting), more like the 2002. 86
 

XOXO
SHIRAZ CABERNET NV, Niagara, Canada, 13.0% D, #016568 $9.95 (Tasted January 1, 2008)  CS

A General listing produced by Andres Wine Ltd. under the label Roundpetal Wines and described as "Medium ruby red colour; aromas of plum, blueberry jam with a hint of spice; It is soft and supple with a fruity finish. Serve with pasta, grilled meat." My notes: Sold also with a chocolate fondue set in Gift Pack #049528 @ $24.95. The XOXO website is about attracting a 'young' crowd, seeming to mean 'sensuous' crowd with Passionate Pairings and Grapelove as themes. The wine has a bright colour, a clear mid ruby and aromas that fail to create any impression, perhaps a faint plum. Light-bodied and flavours that are light raspberry/blueberry, balanced with a light acid and finishing with a touch of fruit, a slight licorice and metallic edge. I didn't get any shiraz nor cabernet context: body, side flavourings or spicy/herby notes, nor oak influences. This in spite of the website claim "Each one integrates fine varietals from great Canadian vineyards and around the world to create something truly special." and "A kiss of rich Cabernet complements a hug of bold Shiraz, intensifying the flavours and aromas of blackberry and blackcurrant". I found it an uninteresting sipper and difficult to envision it enhancing any meal - didn't do anything for a Sub Club. A blend of juices from whatever years and wherever vineyards - ie. not a VQA wine. A commercial beverage in a glitzy package. I would not have this in for friends or family. 72

Statistically speaking

I'm trying to make sense out of last year's tastings. Of three hundred and fifty seven wines, one-sixty-one were white and one-ninety-six were red. Excluding a few gift bottles all were close to or under twenty dollars. Two hundred and three (57%) were from Vintages and one hundred and twenty-one (34%) were from the General shelves. The remainder were purchased directly from a winery.

Of
the Vintages releases, fifty-nine or 29% (twenty-five white and thirty-four reds) showed up in the seventy-nine Favourites for 2007.
Of the General listings, thirteen or 11% (seven whites and six reds) showed up in Favourites.

The countries favoured with the most purchases were Australia (86), Canada (55), Chile (55), and Italy (39). Argentina (29), France (25), USA (22) were in the middle with NZ (17), Spain (12), South Africa (12) sharing the rest except for four from Portugal, one from Germany.

Of the top four countries, my Favourites numbered 21, 7, 15 and 4 respectively. Forty-five of the Canadian wines were whites with four showing up in Favourites and three of the remaining ten showing as red favourites.

The biggest return, by percent, was a combined Argentina and Chile - a total of 84 purchased and 25 Favourites (30%) - Australia came close with 21 favourites from 86 purchases (24%). The biggest return for favourite whites came from NZ (10 of 16), but I love a kiwi sauv blanc more than once in awhile.

What I could deduce from the numbers is:
  • For reds I should purchase from Argentina, Chile and Australia
  • For whites: from NZ, Chile and USA
  • Portugal and Spain: great bubblies
  • France, is generally too pricey to show a benefit
  • Finding a Favourite even with some guidance has been 1:10 (General) to 1:3 (Vintages)
However, and the conclusion I will draw, the wines came from twelve countries giving me a sampling of terroirs and wine methods that vary around the globe. I have visited websites telling me of family traditions, their history and growth over decades and their ambitions for the future. I couldn't have experienced the spread of passion for winemaking if I narrowed my purchases to a few countries or a few wineries. I would like to say thanks to each winery, each winemaker and to each proprietor for not selling out to a large conglomerate. THANKS! And I know I carp about them but thanks also to the LCBO for bringing these wines to me and the local wine critics for their view of the world.

Cheers, Ww

Favourites of 2007

'Favourites of 2007' are based on tastings throughout the year as documented in this blog. The basis for narrowing the 357 wines to the following is a combination of the rating shown and my recall of the aroma and textures invoked by the tasting writeups. If you have tried any of the wines and have similar conclusions - or not - it'll be based on your taste buds and bias, New World or Old, one varietal versus others, etc.. You can't be wrong and you can certainly differ.

Over the past year I have become sensitive to marketing influences on local wine critics - from their accepting luncheons or exclusive event hostings by the wine industry to partisan tastings by various boards or wineries. 'Wine' is a social custom: 'Wine evaluating' is a business. If you do the latter for a living the 'social' should be kept distinct and separate. Putting it another way: if a critic participates in an impartial, controlled tasting it's a tax claim: if not, it's not. But enticements are to be expected among self appointed purveyors of wine recommendations over which there are no legislated or group administered controls. It becomes a 'buyer beware' market and the more an individual consumer does to narrow down wine selections to the quality and values that do exist, the better the payback. Hosting your own wine tasting among friends, touring 'wine country' whether it be local or abroad develops an appreciation for terroirs and raison d'etre for wine varietals, blends and pairings. But not everyone can afford the time or expense. I suggest you skip over the tasting summaries in the wine articles/magazines and glean as much as you can vicariously from their many vineyard travelogs.

So protect yourself from other peoples' opinions, at least until you test them and are confident whatever statements are made or activity planned are in your best interests. And I mean a collective 'your' including friends, family or whoever may be sharing your enthusiasm for wines.

The 'rules' of last year are still valid and I would add a few more:
  • Serious winemakers don't use gimmicks. Look past the name on the bottle unless it adds to a social happening, eg. a bottle of Fat Bastard for a bully of a boss (but find a new job first).
  • Don't take 'Wine Competitions' at face value. The winners may be known beforehand. Personally I find taste-offs such as 'Bordeaux versus Niagara' professionally immature.
  • Don't expect to locate value wines in anthologies of past vintages (including the list below). They are history by publication time.
  • It's best to donate directly to a charity than buy a bottle of bad wine that contributes part of its price to a charity.
I hope the following is useful in some way. The date of the tasting is in brackets.
Happy imbibing! Ww

Reds - of 196 Tastings (including 6 Sparkling and 33 Retastings):

  1. Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon 'Special Selection' 2002, California, USA, #711663 $159.95 (Dec 25) 93
  2. Pillar Box Red Cabernet/Shiraz/Merlot 2004, South Australia, #685941 $14.95 (Dec 27) 90-2
  3. Aramis Vineyards Shiraz 2004, McLaren Vale, South Australia, #041202 $20.95 (Dec 12) 92-2
  4. Katnook 'Founders Block' Sparkling Shiraz 2004, South Australia, #053330 $19.95 (Dec 09) 89-1
  5. Wyndham Estate Shiraz Bin 555 2005, South Eastern Australia, #189415 $16.15 (Dec 08) 91-2
  6. Wyndham Estate Shiraz Bin 555 2004, South Eastern Australia, #189415 $16.15 (Dec 08) 90-2
  7. Wyndham Estate Show Reserve Shiraz 2005*, South Eastern Australia, (in #049692) (Dec 08) 92-2
  8. Step Rd Shiraz 2005, Langhorne Creek, Australia, #052993 $19.95 (Dec 04) 89-1
  9. Rolf Binder Hales Shiraz 2005, Barossa Valley, Australia, #054239 $19.95 (Dec 03) 91-2
  10. Miguel Torres Santa Digna Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve 2005, Chile, #177451 $14.95 (Nov 27) 90-2
  11. Kilikanoon 'The Lackey' Shiraz 2005, Penwortham, Australia, #005199 $17.95 (Nov 12) 92-3
  12. Viu Manent Reserva Carmenere 2005, Colchagua Valley, Chile, #045161 $14.95 (Oct 23) 90-2
  13. J & F Lurton Reserva Cabernet Sauvignon 2005, Uco Valley, Argentina, #591735 $14.95 (Oct 21) 90-2
  14. Bodegas Catena Alamos Malbec 2006, Mendoza, Argentina, #467951 $14.95 (Oct 25) 90-2
  15. Valdiveso Reserva Syrah 2005, Central Valley, Chile, #045153 $17.95 (Oct 15) 90-2
  16. Nepenthe 'The Rogue' Cabernet/Merlot/Shiraz 2003, Adelaide, Australia, #998542 $17.95 (Oct 03) 90-2
  17. Vina Maipo Carmenere Reserva 2006, Rapel Valley, Chile, #663047 $13.95 (Oct 02) 90-2
  18. Tedeschi Capitel Dei Nicalo Valpolicella Classico Superiore 2004, Piedmont Italy, #984997 $16.95 (Oct 01) 90-2
  19. Rancho Zabaco Zinfandel Sonoma Heritage Vines 2001, Sonoma, USA, #434605* $19.95 (Sep 27)  92-2
  20. Santa Julia Malbec Reserva 2005, Mendoza, Argentina, #665026 $13.95 (Sep 24) 90-2
  21. Famiglia Bianchi Cabernet Sauvignon 2002, Mendoza, Argentina, #677567 $15.95 (Sep 03) 92-3
  22. Kaiken Ultra Malbec 2005, Mendoza, Argentina, #050849 $18.95 (Sep 02) 90-2
  23. Lurton Malbec Reserva 2005, Uco Valley, Argentina, #903153 $14.95 (Sep 01) 93-3
  24. Montes Limited Selection Pinot Noir 2006, Casablanca Valley, Chile, #037937 $14.95 (Sep 01) 90-2
  25. Hacienda Araucano Reserva Cabernet Sauvignon 2005, Central Valley, Chile, #687681 $13.95 (Aug 23) GS90
  26. Corte Zovo 'Sa Solin' Ripasso 2004, Veneto, Italy, #650713 $16.95 (Aug 20) NR
  27. X&Y Shiraz 2004, Margaret River, Australia, #041194 $17.95 (Jul 24) NR
  28. Penfolds 'Koonunga Hill' Shiraz/Cabernet 2004, Australia, #285544 $16.15 (Jul 12) NR
  29. Vista Touriga Nacional Berias Red 2004, Portugal, #613919 $13.20* (Jul 05) GS89
  30. Cave Spring Select Late Harvest Cabernet 2005, Niagara, Canada, #630244 $21.95 375mL (Jun 29) GS90
  31. Vina Carmen Reserve Syrah/Cabernet Sauvignon 2004, Maipo Valley, Chile, #983106 $19.95 (Jun 01) NR
  32. Marques de Casa Concha Syrah 2004, Peumo, Chile, #019042 $19.95 (May 02) WS91
  33. Jackson-Triggs Proprietors Grand Reserve Meritage 2001, Jordan, Canada, #594002 $23.95 (Apr 24) NR
  34. Scholz Vintners 'The Willows' Shiraz 2002, Barossa, Australia, #015826 $32.95 (Apr 01) RP93
  35. Concha y Toro Marques De Casa Concha Merlot 2004, Rapel Valley, Chile, #939827 $19.95 (Mar 18) NM90
  36. Trinchero Family Pinot Noir 2005, Napa Valley, USA, #025155 $20.95 (Mar 16)
  37. Errazuriz Max Reserva Merlot 2004, Aconcagua Valley, Chile, #016170 $18.15 (Mar 15) GS90
  38. Finca Flichman Paisaje De Barrancas 2002, Mendoza, Argentina, #017129 $16.95 (Mar 4) AG91
  39. Chateau Des Charmes 'Equuleus' Paul Bosc Vineyard 2002 VQA, NotL, Canada, #Winery $35.00 (Mar 1) NR
  40. Finca Flichman Expresiones Reserve 2005, Mendoza, Argentina, #507707 $15.75 (Feb 5) NM90
  41. St Hallett Cabernet Sauvignon 2004, Barossa, Australia, #015164 $19.95 (Jan 31) NR
  42. Elderton 'The Ashmead Family' Cabernet Sauvignon 2004, Barossa, Australia, #009175 $28.95 (Jan 29) NR
  43. Kilikanoon Killerman's Run Grenache/Shiraz 2003, Australia, #009225 $18.95 (Jan 28) RP91
  44. Finca Flichman Expresiones Reserve Shiraz/Cabernet Sauvignon 2004, Mendoza, Argentina, #017111 $15.95 (Jan 20) NM90
Whites - of 161 Tastings (including 18 Sparkling and 12 Retastings):
  1. Brancott Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc 2006, Marlborough, NZ, #129528 $14.95 (Dec 24) 91-2
  2. Codorniu Non Plus Ultra NV, Penedes, Spain, #053660 $20.95 (Dec 16) 91-2
  3. Konzelmann Sparkling Riesling NV VQA, Niagara, Canada, #031401 $14.95 (Nov 30) 89-2
  4. Villa Maria Private Bin Sauvignon Blanc 2007, Marlborough, NZ, #426601 $16.95 (Nov 25) 91-2
  5. Belcanto Di Bellussi Valdobbiadene VSQPRD, Italy, #053215 $19.95 (Nov 04) 91-2
  6. Aveleda Follies Vinho Verde 2006, Moncao, Portugal, #059048 $15.95 (Oct 24) 90-2
  7. Pillitteri Gewurtraminer/Riesling 2006 Fusion VQA, Niagara, Canada, #349126 $12.95 (Oct 18) 89-2
  8. Angove's Vineyard Select Riesling 2005, Australia, #597054 $12.85 (Oct 14) 89-2
  9. Concha y Toro Winemaker's Lot Chardonnay 2006, Limari Valley, Chile, #030940 $15.95 (Oct 12) 89-2
  10. Mountain Road Wines Co. Reserve Chard 2003 VQA, Beamsville Bench, Niagara, #Winery $26.15 (Oct 09) 92-2
  11. Cousino-Macul Antiguas Reservas Chardonnay 2006, Maipo Valley, Chile, #730044 $14.95 (Oct 02) 90-2
  12. Chateau Ste Michelle Chardonnay 2005, Columbia Valley, USA, #232439 $17.95 (Sep 26) 90-2
  13. Anakena Single Vineyard Viognier 2006, Rapel Valley, Chile, #045138 $15.95 (Sep 17) 90-2
  14. Mount Riley Chardonnay 2005, Marlborough, NZ, #032318 $22.95 (Aug 04) GS90
  15. Ramirana Reserva Chardonnay 2005, Casablanca Valley, Chile, #041434 $14.95 (Aug 02) NR
  16. Vina Carmen Reserve Sauvignon Blanc 2006, Casablanca Valley, Chile, #031096 $13.95 (Jul 20) NR
  17. Mount Riley Sauvignon Blanc 2006, Marlborough, NZ, #981670 $18.95 (Jul 19) NM90
  18. Las Moras Chardonnay Reserva 2005, San Juan, Argentina, #032896 $11.95 (Jul 15) NR
  19. Allimant-Laugner Cremant D'Alsace Brut, Alsace, France, #030593 $19.95 (Jul 11) NR
  20. Yalumba 'The Y Series' Viognier 2006, South Australia, #624502 $15.95 (Jul 08) NR
  21. Stoneleigh Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc 2006, New Zealand, #293043 $15.25 (Jul 01) NR
  22. Seresin Sauvignon Blanc 2006, Marlborough, NZ, #735043 $19.75 (Jun 28) NR
  23. Hardys Nottage Hill Chardonnay 2006, South Australia, #283457 $11.00 (Jun 28) NR
  24. Mike Weir Estate Sauvignon Blanc 2006, Niagara, Canada, #686972 $15.15 (Jun 08) NR
  25. Sileni Cellar Selection Pinot Gris 2006, Hawkes Bay, NZ, #032393 $15.95 (May 27) NR
  26. Mumm Carte Classique, Champagne, France, #308064 $53.15 (May 20) NR
  27. Clifford Bay Sauvignon Blanc 2006, Marlborough, NZ, #734095 $19.95 (May 15) NM90
  28. Ninth Island Pinot Grigio 2006, Tasmania, Australia, #683193 $20.95 (Apr 02) NR
  29. Kim Crawford Sauvignon Blanc 2006, Marlborough, NZ, #035386 $19.95 (Apr 2) NM90
  30. Grove Mill Pinot Gris 2005, Marlborough, NZ, #001693 $19.95 (Mar 25) NR
  31. Montresor Capitel Alto Soave Classico 2004, Veneto, Italy, #531673 $12.85 (Feb 26) NR
  32. Laxas Albarino 2005, Rias Baixas, Spain, #021477 $19.75 (Feb 07) NR
  33. Clover Hill Sparkling Wine 2001, Tasmania, Australia, #588236 $34.95 (Jan 24) NR
  34. La Crema Chardonnay 2005, Sonoma Coast, USA, #962886 $26.95 (Jan 7) NR
  35. Robert Mondavi 'Napa Valley' Fume Blanc 2004, Calif, USA, #221887 $24.96 (Jan 04) NR
AG - Anthony Gismondi, GS - Gord Stimmell, NM - Natalie MacLean, NR - Not Rated, RP - Robert Parker, WS - Wine Spectator

Sunday, December 23, 2007

Marketers, Critics or Ombudsmen?

During a morning read of the latest tastings and recommendations from the several wine critics I follow I had an epiphany!
I've been under the impression wine critics are the equivalent of other 'critics', just in a different venue, wine instead of theatre, arts, politics, etc. Movie critics have often praised, panned, slashed and burned movies describing faults, the story line and the acting and cinematographic merits. They take no prisoners in their review of moviedoms releases. Crud is crud, gold is gold in their view and they're not hesitant to print it. Similarly, art critics can be highly caustic or complimentary of an artist's passion. Political analysts or parliament watchers report with the only caution they don't cross the line called libel in their presentation of political shenanigans.
The movie, theatre, art and political critics all have one thing in common. They're working for you the reader. They don't represent MGM, Sony, Mirvish Productions, the ROM or AGO, Liberals, PCs, etc. but offer their trained observations so you have considerably more on which to base your own opinion. Whether you agree or not you now have more things to think about.
My epiphany was to suddenly realize wine critics are very much different - at least in some cases or on occasion, perhaps on all occasions. Until it becomes apparent in their words they should be looked at as an extension of the wine industry's Marketing organization. Maybe they are paid by someone else but they are essentially selling product under the assumption of impartiality. Notice how often I've said 'some' or 'on some occasions' and 'some more often than not' because how would anyone know for sure? There is no written 'code of conduct' that I know of - except...
In the US Robert Parker Jr. claims he spends three months of the year tasting in vineyards and nine months tasting sometimes seven days a week and putting his observations in writing. His website lists the conditions for his tasting of wines which, I believe would ensure consistency and independence as a critic. Hopefully I can summarize the salient points of the conditions he claims his Company works under:
  • When possible tastings are of the same type of wines and the producer's names are not known (blind and peer)
  • Neither price nor producer's reputation is a factor
  • He does not take part in wine judgings or trade tastings
  • Tastings are from an entire bottle in appropriate tasting glasses and at the proper wine temperature
  • He determines the amount of time needed for the number of wines to be tasted
  • Wines may be tasted several times with the rating reflecting the overall results
  • He prefers to underestimate than overestimate a wine
  • His rating system, 50 - 100 point scale, is intended to enhance and complement his tasting notes
If these conditions were not adhered to the results could easily be influenced by the winery owner, the distributor, the retailer, ie. those marketing the wine. Robert Parker's conditions puts a buffer between these influences and his clients. And if you subscribe to his tasting results, through his website or a subscription to The Wine Advocate, you should benefit from this impartiality.
I don't claim to certify that these conditions are being followed on all or any occasion but, to me, they have a ring of legitimacy. What I would say is his assessment and reporting on hundreds of wines in many countries has resulted in a very successful business and a worldwide reputation. To a large degree this authenticates the process.
There must be some in Canada having basically a similar ethic. Do you know who they are?
Having followed magazine articles, newpaper columns, wine medal results, etc. I cannot recall when a Canadian wine critic has documented anywhere similar conditions for tastings imposed by himself or the panel on which he/she has sat. As I say, I've had an epiphany. I no longer have the same confidence in published tastings that I've had in the past. Perhaps some day there will be a Wine Critics Guild with a documented 'Conditions for Tasting' and I could be more confident in what is published. (Imagine! A tasters column having WCG after the critic's name to signify his oath of independence.) Until then I have to start with the assumption that local wine critics are Marketers.
I have some 'what ifs' :
  • What if Ontario critics insisted on certain groundrules for their tastings (as above)? Better still... what if NO reviewer showed up at LCBO tastings without these conditions being met?
  • What if, each or collectively, reviewers listed the wines they wanted to taste.... would the LCBO make them available or not?
  • What if critics reviewed more of the plonk sitting unsuspectingly on LCBO shelves? If there were a column, say monthly, of 10 wines with ratings in the 70s readers would know how to avoid bad to mediocre wines whether local or imported. I believe gradually these labels would disappear. The local wine industry would see fewer labels competing with their lower priced brands and the Industry as a whole would be healthier.
  • What if there were a regular list of US (NY State?) versus Ontario wine prices. Recently there was a huge outcry over books, greeting cards and cars, however pricing of liquor products has been inflated so long we accept being gouged. Wine is a drink for family and friends, not just the rich and famous.
With an increasing focus on profit the LCBO isn't doing a good enough job of policing its shelves. Customers need an ombudsman to ensure it's honouring its monopoly status. Wouldn't it be great if Ontario reviewers became our ombudsmen?
My opinion, Ww